NAHBS 2017: The Construction Awards

NAHBS 2017: The Construction Awards

There’s no way to pussyfoot around this. Brad Bingham, the welder at Kent Eriksen Cycles, frustrates me. He has won the best TIG-welding award for each of the last five years. No one else exhibiting at NAHBS has been nearly as successful. The best TIG-welding award is, as a result of Bingham’s unparalleled excellence, is the most boring award to give.

IMG_4192

That last statement deserves some explanation.

The thing about Bingham’s work is that he’s always a step ahead of the competition. We were able to find the start and stop point for only one weld on the bike he built for the best TIG category.

IMG_4193

The point to this rant-ette is that as long as Bingham enters a frame for best TIG weldding, he’s likely to continue winning. Could I restrict him from entering the category? I could. But that would be a disservice to the awards and the builders. My job as a judge is to recognize the best work at the show. That’s entirely independent of whether or not someone has won previously. So while I’d love to recognize some of the other amazing builders who TIG their frames, my job isn’t to recognize all the good work, it is to recognize the best work.

And Brad Bingham is the best TIG welder working in the bike industry. He took the Merlin stack-of-dimes and turned it into a stack of cards. We might as well just put his name on the award for next year.

IMG_4195

That Bingham didn’t bead-blast the finished frame, thereby disguising this bike’s heat affected zone, was a significant step in us recognizing his frame for what it was: exemplary. We do what we can to encourage all the builders to do this, but it doesn’t always work.

IMG_4196

Now, al that said, I need to recognize the entrants in the category because this was the best competition we’ve had since Charlotte. There was one frame with no decal or head tube badge that also hadn’t been bead-blasted that demonstrated incredible work. I hope to find out who produced that frame today. I never found out. I was doing something else when it was picked up.

IMG_4197

Dave Kirk won for best fillet brazing. He brought a stunning frame with thin webs between the tubes like those between your fingers. I’d seen a couple of photos of this frameset on social media ahead of the show and knew it would be a contender. When we arrived in the judging paddock, it was clearly the superior frame, despite the quality of the other entrants.

IMG_4203

What I couldn’t see in in the photos on the Internet was how he managed to create those thin edges by using small pieces of sheet metal. He tacked them in and then began adding brass.

IMG_4202

IMG_4199

What these photos can’t show is Kirk’s incredible control. His ability to apply brass perfectly symmetrically is something even exceptionally skilled builders struggle with. So aside from the webs he created, the symmetricality of these fillets was something that other builders would admire. Finally, in almost every builder’s work you’ll see the occasional pit or pinhole. They are like a cavity in a tooth, just a tiny little void. They are a sign of a tiny issue in heat control. I believe I found only one in this frame. That might be a record among frames I’ve seen.

IMG_4204

Alchemy won best layup. Where best fillet and best TIG welding had clear winners, best layup was incredibly difficult. Alchemy was facing off against Argonaut and Argonaut provided a frame with three cutaway sections so that we could look inside. The best layup category has never seen such stiff competition.

IMG_4209

Ultimately, what gave the competition to Alchemy were a few factors. This disc brake mount was integrated beautifully into the chainstay, and while the Allen bolt heads would protrude on the underside of the chainstay, because there was no recess in the mount—understandably, given that would mean removing carbon fiber from the frame—the mount itself was elegant.

IMG_4208

The other thing that Alchemy did that I’ve found extraordinary was its use of plies of carbon fiber in a decorative fashion. The model name and logo were both cut from carbon fiber. Additionally, small rings and stripes were added to give the frame the guiding hand of a graphic designer.

IMG_4207

This isn’t new to Alchemy or even unique to them. I was disappointed I couldn’t see more inside the frame, I’ve seen plenty of work from Alchemy to know they do work superior to an Asian sweat shop. Also, I want to add that even though the competition really came down to Alchemy and Argonaut the presence of another A company—Allied—gave us the far stiffest competition we have seen in this category.

I am disappointed to report that we received no entries in the competition for best lugs. It’s here that I must acknowledge that the construction categories ask a lot of a builder. If you want to impress people, painting a frame and building it into an entire bike is the thing to do. There’s no denying this. But if you want to prove that your work can measure up against a guy like Mark DiNucci or Dave Kirk, you need to be prepared to show your work.

 


If you value independent media, please lend your support to RKP.


Subscriber Options



To learn more about our new subscription program, please read this.

, , , , ,

5 comments

  1. Trey

    Outside of the visual differences between a TIG welded frame and brazed frame what does each method offer a frame or rider? Does it produce a different feel, riding response, stiffness, etc. or is it strictly a stylistic choice?

  2. ChinookPass

    Good stuff. I would love to know more about how you judge a carbon layup.
    Nothing in best lugs? Maybe there needs to be a larger incentive?


    1. Author
      Padraig

      In carbon layup, there are a number of things we look for, but the big one we are looking for is a clean, ripple- and wrinkle-free outer finish. You’d be amazed how often we find something that kills an entrant, though this year we had more qualified entrants than ever before. We also want to see a clean inside, to the degree that we can see inside. Argonaut raised the bar by bringing a frame with cutaway sections. It was an impressive effort. What carried the day this time were the decorative layers that the Alchemy featured, especially the logo and model name done in carbon.

      As to the lack of entrants in the lugged category this year, it’s more a function of what a big ask it is for a builder to bring a frame that is unpainted. From the standpoint of the awards, it’s something we really need to request, but for the exhibitor, a bare frame is about the least sexy thing you can show most attendees. The upshot is that many builders are willing to forego a possible award in favor of wowing the crowds. I understand completely.

  3. Rob B

    Frustrating, maybe sure. But my new-in-November Eriksen is a most elegant creation that invites close examination. And when one does that, the details shine. And the DK bike is a stunner in steel. Thanks for praising with faint damns and helping highlight some of our great American frame builders.
    Next year NAHB is in Hartford CT, do I read? That is close enough to go to. A highlight of next winter already.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *