Astana: Chaos

Tour de France Stage 20 Ventoux 26/05/09

The Astana team was the single most interesting story at this year’s Tour de France because it was really the only story of the 2009 Tour de France. Without Astana, Saxo Bank would have all but raced away from the rest of the field. During the Tour the conflict emanated from Lance Armstrong’s and Alberto Contador’s dual desires to win the Tour de France. That conflict produced a lot of collateral damage; top was Contador’s relationship with team director Johan Bruyneel. Additionally, rider relationships suffered and even tension emerged between some of the riders and support staff.

Things got weirder even before the Tour ended. Bruyneel had made it known that Alexander Vinokourov wasn’t exactly welcome at Astana. Bruyneel’s lack of interest in working with Astana’s raison d’etre is understandable; he has enough trouble projecting the image that Astana is a team of clean riders without accepting into the fold a rider coming back from a two-year suspension. As a result, Vinokourov issued the classic ultimatum: him or me. So Bruyneel announced his departure and told the Dutch newspaper De Telegraaf, “The reason for my leaving is that Vinokourov is back riding with Astana.”

Indications are that Bruyneel and Vinokourov have reached an uneasy truce by keeping their distance; Bruyneel hasn’t been seen at races Vinokourov in which has competed. It seemed a reasonable solution—avoid each other until Bruyneel’s exit to The Shack.

Which brings up the exodus. Armstrong’s exit was quick and easy; because he was unpaid he never had a contract—boom, he’s gone. Contador wants out but as been reported ad infinitum, he’s got another year on his contract and Astana hasn’t wanted to allow him to buy out his contract. Team Radio Shack has signed Andreas Kloden, Levi Leipheimer, Chris Horner, Yaroslav Popovych, Haimar Zubeldia, Gregory Rast, Thomas Vaitkus and Sergio Paulinho. Swiss riders Steve Morabito and Michael Schar are leaving for BMC. That’s 11 of 28 riders leaving only four riders (Contador, Vinokourov, Dmitriy Muravyev and José Luis Rubiera) who have competed in the Tour de France.

Not so fast. Astana management have noticed the shrinking team and have put the kibosh on the departures of Kloden, Popovych, Zubeldia and Rast. Normally, a support rider buying out his contract is as eventful as purchasing batteries at Radio Shack, but while Astana’s management may have trouble making payroll (the final $2 million installment for the 2009 season has not yet been paid), they can do the math: If the Kazakhstan government loses the sport’s most successful director and every rider who wants to leave, the only veteran left from this year’s Tour de France team will be the beneficiary of Kazakhstan’s version of Affirmative Action: Dmitriy Muravyev. Were all these departures to take place, there’s no way the team would keep its ProTour license which would make it largely irrelevant as an international statement of cycling prowess.

The surprise here is that Astana’s management hasn’t done more to bolster the team by replacing those who have left or want to leave. If you consider just those riders who have definitely left—Armstrong, Leipheimer, Horner, Paulinho, Vaitkus, Morabito and Schar—the team is decimated and needs some serious recruiting. So why isn’t this happening?

The answer may lie in Contador’s woes. He has reported that each time he has a meeting with Astana management that meeting is followed by another meeting in which the new team representative discredits the previous team representative. Contador’s brother and agent, Fran, has refused to negotiate further until team leadership is clarified. If there’s no clear management structure in place (and that seems a reasonable conclusion) then it isn’t terribly surprising what little management there is agrees every rider who can be retained should be.

As a management strategy, it’s very short sighted. Riders can be expected to assist each other at key race times because they will want to have something for their palmarés when it’s time to negotiate with another team. However, morale will suffer and performances will suffer and that will hurt their value, which is why its imperative for Kloden and the rest to get out now. Bruyneel could sit on his hands for the year and The Shack would still want him for 2011; he’d be wanted anywhere.

There’s still time for a happy ending, though not much and perhaps not quite everyone.

Without any new signings, Astana will fall below the 25-rider minimum that the ProTour requires. Without 25 riders the team loses its ProTour status (one can imagine a last-ditch effort by the Kazakhstan government to give a license to any citizen who has won a bike race). With the team’s loss of its ProTour license, Contador could invoke a clause in his contract that grants his release should the team lose its ProTour status. This is one problem a new sponsor’s money can’t solve.

How many teams would have the funds to pay Contador at such a late date? It could be a stretch for Caisse d’Epargne and Contador isn’t likely to accept a cut in pay. However, word is Jonathan Vaughters has a sponsor waiting in the wings; should he land Contador, Garmin-Slipstream becomes Garmin-Somethingelse and Contador gets paid what he’s worth. That might finally give Vaughters reason enough to let Wiggins out of his contract so he can ride for Team Sky, which has more than enough budget to pay him what he’s worth as well as give him unquestioned leadership. A confidential source familiar with the team tells me Wiggins hates the management at Garmin-Slipstream and is desperate to leave.

Were Contador to finally escape Astana a new question would arise. What then of Bruyneel, Kloden, Zubeldia, Popovych and Rast? There’s no word on whether the five have similar ProTour requirement clauses in their contracts. Even if Astana management held them hostage for a year, it is unlikely the team could accomplish much. But after all the turmoil the great irony would be to see Bruyneel manage a decimated Astana led by Vinokourov—the only two people who stated publicly they would never work together, bound to the same team.

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


  1. James

    Whatever happens, Contador on Garmin, Wiggins on Sky, The Shack and throw in Schlecks… could makes for some great racing in the next Tour.

    1. Author

      If everyone goes to the team they wish, the 2010 Tour should feature four teams truly capable of winning the Tour. I can’t wait (though I’ll have to).

  2. Henry

    Am I reading your article right? Bruyneel may be tied up with contractual obligations to Astana for 2010? There is the possibility that Astana could lose their license making Contador a free agent but Bruyneel may be stuck with the Kazaks! Wow, that would be an unexpected twist.

  3. Author

    Great question George. Theo de Rooy is available, though Astana passed on him. Hans Michael Holczer is available as well. The bigger question might be whether or not Armstrong would believe that he could win without him.

  4. Henry

    I’m finding it hard to believe Bruyneel would have held a press conference during the Tour announcing his new team (for which he and Lance recruited most of Astana’s top talent) without knowing for sure he could actually lead Armstrong’s new venture. After the Td’F circus in the Astana tent during the Tour that would be hilarious. He sinks the Astana ship with everyone thinking Contador will be stuck on it only to find out he’s still going to be Captain and it’s Contador who won’t be on the crew. Or if they don’t lose their license Bruyneel will be depending on Vino and Contador next year as his go to guys. Even more hilarious.

    I’m pretty sure he checked his contract and had his ducks in a row, but if he didn’t. again. Wow.

  5. lachlan

    And most of this we can pretty much blame squarely at Mr Astana himself… Vino. Right? Without his transfussions none of the chain of bizarre events would have started!

    The soap opera continues :o)

  6. andrew

    did wiggins hate the garmin management so much before his meteoric rise in this year’s TdF? he rode well, but the team rode very very well and helped his cause. sure he will likely do great anywhere, but his post-tour attitude is much different than his attitude during the spring.

    1. Author

      It’s fair to wonder if Wiggin’s attitude can’t be summed up as old-fashioned nouveau ego. However, it is possible that his year hasn’t been a happy one top to bottom and he’s only felt secure enough to speak up since his Tour finish.

  7. hida yanra

    as of today:
    JB is out, Yvon Sanquer is in
    If Astana has money they will be able to find riders somewhere. There are plenty of pro cyclists out of work from folded teams or otherwise, they won’t lose their license over that.

    For the sake of the spectacle next year I hope that Contador races on a team that can support him at least a bit.

    1. Author

      Apparently Bruyneel must have talked some sense to the Kazakh government, sense they understood. Not only has Bruyneel been released, but so has Kloden, Popovych and Rast. It’s great news for The Shack and terrible news for Astana’s desire to remain in the ProTour. Zubeldia, however, has not been released at the request of Alberto Contador. One wonders if Contador manages to engineer his exit if he will take Zubeldia with him or leave him to twist.

      Directors Dirk Demol, Alain Gallopin and Viatcheslav Ekimov have moved to The Shack as well, leaving Astana’s management structure decimated as well.

      As for Yvon Sanquer, Astana’s new boss, he is one of very few directors who could virtually ensure the team’s anonymity in the future. His past years with Mutuelle de Seine et Marne were uneventful as were his years with Festina (’99-’01, post Festina’s productive and team-organized doping years).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *